Lab vs Golden retriever for upland, ducks , grouse and best friend?

Discussion in 'General Discussion' started by cmrosko, May 24, 2016.

  1. cmrosko

    cmrosko Member

    799
    0
    16
    I am looking for input from hunters with experience where they would be able to give input comparing the breeds Lab vs Golden retriever for upland, ducks , grouse and best friend? (would include watch dog to a lesser degree but is also a plus)
    Thanks for your input.
     
  2. peanut

    peanut Active Member

    1,192
    7
    38
    Im a lab guy. So for ducks and best friend, lab. For upland/grouse, golden. They make good friends too!

    Ive hunted pheasants and grouse over at least six of my buddies goldens. All very good. That being said, he now has a black lab who's parents are grand master/champions, and she is an upland MACHINE.

    Hard to say, as I feel either can be molded into whatever you want???
     

  3. Cedar17

    Cedar17 New Member

    48
    0
    0
    Do you have two litters picked out? That would help with more specific answers.
     
  4. Dan_O

    Dan_O Well-Known Member

    3,770
    95
    48
    Have had both several times, spent big money on each. Training was identical for all. Goldens are nice, but would go with great pedigree Black lab over great pedigree golden every time. There are inexpensive dogs that are great, but the odds are more in your favor if you go with a dog with a great pedigree. In most cases, that ain't cheap.
     
  5. EaglePoint

    EaglePoint 1 more pass? No Way!

    9,404
    1
    38
    Agree with Dan. One thing to add: GR in general doesn't quite have the cold weather stamina of the lab. My advice is research some bloodlines and pedigrees, make some calls and spend the few extra hundred to get that right fit. My next dog will be black with a good pedigree.
     
  6. Kaiser878

    Kaiser878 Member

    563
    4
    18
    There ya go.... might have one lined up for tou. :D



    I'm a lab guy.... Goldens have to many quarks for me.... they are great dogs, but there's a reason why labs are the most used dog for hunting birds... do your research, and be selective...

    Money shouldn't be an object, within reason... ive owned back yard bred and I've owned high end.... I will never own anyrhing but a stacked pedigree dog ever again.... there's a reason why they cost double or triple what a back yard bred dog costs...

    Also look at health clearances. You want at a minimum for your dog to have parents who have been tested for hips,elbows, eyes, cnm and eic... and this day and age, a dilute gene test... thanks to all the asshats breeding silvers...

    Check dogs out on entry express and huntinglabpedigree.com pedigree once you find a breeding you like... that way you can see their performance history ad well as their health clearances...

    There are endless resources out there.
     
  7. cmrosko

    cmrosko Member

    799
    0
    16
    Last edited: May 27, 2016
  8. Kaiser878

    Kaiser878 Member

    563
    4
    18
    Flame is a good dog....

    The female doesn't seem to be registered through entry express or hunting lab pedigree.. which only means she hasn't competed or ran tests.... not big deal..

    Does the female have health clearances.?
     
    Last edited: May 28, 2016
  9. cmrosko

    cmrosko Member

    799
    0
    16
    Yes, the Dam, Medlin's Red Point Foxy, has all health clearances for akc registration breeding.

    She passed a JR hunt test in February in Monterey Ca.. She is a seasoned bird hunter. Her owner is an avid grouse hunter and grouse hunts in Wisconsin and Ontario. She's also hunted quail in TX. and pheasant in CA., and hunts upland birds in Ohio. The owner's main reason for this breeding was to get a male and female for himself and his daughter.
    Foxy comes from a very good hunting line on both sides from a breeder in Mi. who's been breeding hunting line pointing fox yellow labs since the early 90's. Her Dam was Stosh's Red Cedar Point, daughter of Helm's Point Dr. PT., an outstanding pointing lab that Outdoor life wrote about some years ago.

    I'm loving this pup... he's helped heal some of the ache of the loss of my 12 yr. old hunting bud and best friend Skyler in October.
     
    Last edited: May 29, 2016
  10. TDT

    TDT Member

    274
    0
    16
    I have had both over the years, my last two dogs have been labs. That being said for me labs hands down and while pedigree is nice and can give you a solid pup training is the key with any dog.Good hunting dogs are not an accident they are the result of lots of labor and love.
     
  11. Kaiser878

    Kaiser878 Member

    563
    4
    18
    You can't train drive, marking ability, memory ability or most imoortantly, trainability.... that's bred into dogs...

    It also depends on what your expectations are in an animal... some people's expectations are lower
     
  12. Wingnut

    Wingnut Member

    484
    1
    18
    Well said!